The Effect of Structure on Acid–Base Properties — Question 6

Section 14-9 · Chemistry pages 2457–2458

Show solutionHide solution

Question 6

Test how an inductive effect weakens with distance

Hypothetical matched carboxylic acids have pKa values 2.8 for an electron-withdrawing substituent at position 2, 4.0 at position 3, and 4.6 at position 4, measured under identical conditions.

Diagram shown in the original SVG worksheet.

  1. Rank acid strengths and calculate the position-2/position-4 Ka ratio.

  2. Explain what the pattern supports and what it does not prove.

Question 6 - Solution

Test how an inductive effect weakens with distance

Diagram shown in the original SVG worksheet.

(a) Reasoning and result

Position 2 is strongest, then 3, then 4. The ratio is 104.6−2.8=63.110^{4.6-2.8}=63.1.

(b) Analysis

The decrease with distance is consistent with an inductive effect transmitted through bonds. It does not alone exclude changes in conformation, solvation or other structural influences.

Check and interpretation

The values are hypothetical controlled data; do not treat them as tabulated constants for named compounds.