Show solutionHide solution
Question 9
Account for solvation in a basicity comparison
Hypothetical amines X and Y have gas-phase protonation free energies favoring Y by 8 kJ mol. In water, the total differential solvation correction disfavors Y relative to X by 14 kJ mol. Both numbers refer to the same protonation direction and standard-state convention.
Diagram shown in the original SVG worksheet.
Find the net aqueous difference and identify the favored protonation.
Explain why a gas-phase ordering can reverse in solution.
Question 9 - Solution
Account for solvation in a basicity comparison
Diagram shown in the original SVG worksheet.
(a) Reasoning and result
kJ mol in water. X protonation is more favorable under these supplied conditions.
(b) Analysis
Solution protonation includes solvation of both the neutral base and its conjugate acid. Differential stabilization can outweigh the intrinsic gas-phase preference.
Check and interpretation
The signs refer to whole protonation free energies, avoiding double counting individual solvent terms.