Solutions of Acids or Bases Containing a Common Ion — Question 10

Section 15-1 · Chemistry pages 2545–2546

Show solutionHide solution

Question 10

Retain water when both reservoirs are extremely dilute

Assume ideal dilute aqueous behavior at 25 ∘^\circC, Kw=1.00×10−14K_w=1.00\times10^{-14}, and concentrations in mol L−1^{-1} unless stated otherwise. A mixture has formal HA concentration C and formal NaA concentration S, each 10−810^{-8} M, with Ka=10−5K_a=10^{-5}. Let h denote total hydronium.

Diagram shown in the original SVG worksheet.

  1. Derive a single equation including water and the sodium counterion.

  2. Explain why the ratio shortcut predicts an impossible charge balance here.

Question 10 - Solution

Retain water when both reservoirs are extremely dilute

Diagram shown in the original SVG worksheet.

(a) Reasoning and result

Total acid family is T=C+ST=C+S. Then [A−]=TKa/(Ka+h)[A^-]=TK_a/(K_a+h) and [Na+]=S[Na^+]=S. Charge balance is h+S=TKa/(Ka+h)+Kw/hh+S=TK_a/(K_a+h)+K_w/h.

(b) Analysis

The shortcut gives h=KaC/S=10−5h=K_aC/S=10^{-5} M, but the total anion family is only 2×10−82\times10^{-8} M and hydroxide is 10−910^{-9} M at that h. Negative charge cannot balance the proposed positive charge. The full model instead approaches near-neutral water.

Check and interpretation

Absolute inventories matter even when a formal acid/base ratio is unchanged.