Show solutionHide solution
Question 8
Interpret a qualitative test without assuming uniqueness
Assume ideal dilute aqueous behavior at 25 C, , and concentrations in mol L unless stated otherwise. Under controlled conditions, reagent X precipitates M and N but not P; reagent Y precipitates N and P but not M. An unknown gives a precipitate with both reagents in separate aliquots.
Diagram shown in the original SVG worksheet.
Identify the ion if exactly one of M, N and P is present.
Explain why the result is ambiguous if mixtures are allowed and propose the kind of extra evidence needed.
Question 8 - Solution
Interpret a qualitative test without assuming uniqueness
Diagram shown in the original SVG worksheet.
(a) Reasoning and result
If exactly one ion is present, it must be N because N responds to both tests.
(b) Analysis
A mixture of M and P would also give both positive tests. Add a selective separation or a third independent test that distinguishes N from the combination, with positive and negative controls and adequate detection sensitivity.
Check and interpretation
Positive patterns depend on assumptions about sample composition; two positive tests are not automatic unique identification.