Show solutionHide solution
Question 2
Specify the constraints before predicting a direction
Two equal rigid compartments initially hold ideal gases at the same temperature but different pressures. A valve connects them. In a separate experiment, a compressor continually maintains the pressure difference.
Diagram shown in the original SVG worksheet.
Predict the long-term pressure behavior after opening the valve with no compressor.
Explain why a maintained difference is not a counterexample to spontaneous equilibration.
Question 2 - Solution
Specify the constraints before predicting a direction
Diagram shown in the original SVG worksheet.
(a) Reasoning and result
Net flow initially goes from the higher-pressure compartment toward the lower-pressure one. In the closed connected system, mechanical equilibrium ultimately requires equal pressure, with transient temperature effects allowed.
(b) Analysis
The compressor supplies work and changes the surroundings. The maintained state is driven; it is not the equilibrium of the isolated pair. The boundary must include the power source when accounting for the overall process.
Check and interpretation
The constraint of no external driving is essential to the first prediction.