Show solutionHide solution
Question 7
Decide when removing a partition creates mixing entropy
Two equal-volume chambers contain equal amounts of ideal gas at equal temperature and pressure. Case I has gas A on both sides; case II has distinct gases A and B. Ignore the material volume of the partition.
Diagram shown in the original SVG worksheet.
Compare the thermodynamic mixing entropy on removing the partition.
Explain why attaching imaginary labels to identical A particles must not change the physical prediction.
Question 7 - Solution
Decide when removing a partition creates mixing entropy
Diagram shown in the original SVG worksheet.
(a) Reasoning and result
Case I has no macroscopic mixing entropy: the initial and final bulk state of the same gas is unchanged. Case II has positive mixing entropy because each distinct component gains access to the full volume.
(b) Analysis
Bookkeeping labels are not distinct chemical species that can be separated by a selective membrane. Counting artificial permutations as new physical states would incorrectly assign entropy to removing a partition in a uniform gas.
Check and interpretation
The distinction concerns physically distinguishable species, not our ability to name particles.