Spontaneous Processes and Entropy — Question 9

Section 16-1 · Chemistry pages 2703–2704

Show solutionHide solution

Question 9

Choose the system boundary for a spontaneous observation

A salt dissolves in water in an insulated cup and the solution cools. A student says that cooling proves dissolution cannot be spontaneous because energy is being absorbed.

Diagram shown in the original SVG worksheet.

  1. Identify what the observation establishes about the process and the thermal change.

  2. Explain why enthalpy alone cannot determine the favored direction.

Question 9 - Solution

Choose the system boundary for a spontaneous observation

Diagram shown in the original SVG worksheet.

(a) Reasoning and result

Dissolution occurred under the experimental conditions. In a suitable constant-pressure calorimetric interpretation, a drop in temperature indicates that the dissolution draws thermal energy from the rest of the cup contents.

(b) Analysis

Spontaneity depends on the entropy change of the complete system plus surroundings. Increased accessible configurations can outweigh an unfavorable energy contribution; the sign of the heat of dissolution alone is insufficient.

Check and interpretation

The cup contents change temperature, so a constant-temperature formula requires additional modeling.