Show solutionHide solution
Question 8
Choose the potential that matches the constraints
A closed vessel is held at constant temperature and rigid volume. A second closed vessel is held at constant temperature and pressure. Neither receives externally imposed non-pressure work. Define and .
Diagram shown in the original SVG worksheet.
Derive the spontaneous-change criterion for the rigid vessel using .
Identify the corresponding potential for the constant-pressure vessel and explain why constraints matter.
Question 8 - Solution
Choose the potential that matches the constraints
Diagram shown in the original SVG worksheet.
(a) Reasoning and result
For the rigid vessel, . Thus A decreases in a spontaneous irreversible change at fixed T,V.
(b) Analysis
At fixed T,P, with only pressure-volume work, the analogous criterion is decreasing G. The energy exchanged with the mechanical surroundings differs, so the same potential is not automatically appropriate under both sets of constraints.
Check and interpretation
A is Helmholtz energy; it is introduced here only to clarify the limits of the Gibbs criterion.