Free Energy — Question 10

Section 16-4 · Chemistry pages 2765–2766

Show solutionHide solution

Question 10

Use the full definition when temperature is not constant

A sample has H1=20.0H_1=20.0 kJ, S1=50.0S_1=50.0 J K−1^{-1} at T1=300T_1=300 K, and H2=26.0H_2=26.0 kJ, S2=65.0S_2=65.0 J K−1^{-1} at T2=400T_2=400 K.

Diagram shown in the original SVG worksheet.

  1. Calculate G1G_1, G2G_2 and ΔG\Delta G directly.

  2. Explain why ΔH−TΔS\Delta H-T\Delta S with one arbitrarily chosen T is invalid for these endpoints.

Question 10 - Solution

Use the full definition when temperature is not constant

Diagram shown in the original SVG worksheet.

(a) Reasoning and result

G1=20.0−300(0.0500)=5.00G_1=20.0-300(0.0500)=5.00 kJ; G2=26.0−400(0.0650)=0G_2=26.0-400(0.0650)=0. Thus ΔG=−5.00\Delta G=-5.00 kJ.

(b) Analysis

The exact difference is ΔG=ΔH−(T2S2−T1S1)\Delta G=\Delta H-(T_2S_2-T_1S_1). Only at constant T can the second term be written as TΔST\Delta S. These changing-temperature endpoints also do not by themselves establish the fixed-T spontaneity criterion.

Check and interpretation

G is defined at each state even when the convenient constant-temperature difference formula does not apply.