Free Energy and Chemical Reactions — Question 9

Section 16-6 · Chemistry pages 2803–2804

Show solutionHide solution

Question 9

Identify inconsistent thermodynamic data

For one hypothetical reaction at 300 K, a report lists ΔrH∘=+12.0\Delta_rH^\circ=+12.0 kJ/mol, ΔrS∘=+50.0\Delta_rS^\circ=+50.0 J/mol K and ΔrG∘=+3.0\Delta_rG^\circ=+3.0 kJ/mol. All values supposedly refer to the same phases and standard states.

Diagram shown in the original SVG worksheet.

  1. Check internal consistency and state the Gibbs energy implied by H and S.

  2. Find the entropy that would instead be required if the reported H and G were correct.

Question 9 - Solution

Identify inconsistent thermodynamic data

Diagram shown in the original SVG worksheet.

(a) Reasoning and result

ΔrG∘=12.0−300(0.0500)=−3.00\Delta_rG^\circ=12.0-300(0.0500)=-3.00 kJ/mol, not +3.0. The set is inconsistent by 6.0 kJ/mol.

(b) Analysis

The alternative entropy would be (12000−3000)/300=30.0(12000-3000)/300=30.0 J/mol K. The report alone does not establish which datum is wrong; units, phases and source transcription should be checked.

Check and interpretation

Independent routes to a state-function difference should agree within the data uncertainties.