Commercial Electrolytic Processes — Question 9

Section 17-8 · Chemistry pages 3023–3024

Show solutionHide solution

Question 9

Compare voltage savings with current-efficiency losses

Two hypothetical processes make the same product with the same electron stoichiometry. A operates at 3.00 V and 90.0 percent current efficiency; B operates at 2.70 V and 80.0 percent efficiency. Ignore auxiliaries and use constant conditions.

Diagram shown in the original SVG worksheet.

  1. Derive a quantity proportional to electrical energy per mole of product and decide which process uses less.

  2. At equal current, compare product rates. At equal product rate, find the ratio of required currents IB/IAI_B/I_A.

Question 9 - Solution

Compare voltage savings with current-efficiency losses

Diagram shown in the original SVG worksheet.

(a) Reasoning and result

For a product requiring z electrons, Q=zF/ηQ=zF/\eta per mole and W=zFV/ηW=zFV/\eta. Compare V/ηV/\eta: A gives 3.33333 V and B 3.375 V. B uses 1.0125 times A energy, or 1.25 percent more despite its lower voltage.

(b) Analysis

Product rate is ηI/(zF)\eta I/(zF). At equal current B makes 0.80/0.90=8/90.80/0.90=8/9 as much product per time. At equal rate B needs IB/IA=0.90/0.80=1.125I_B/I_A=0.90/0.80=1.125.

Check and interpretation

Voltage alone is not an adequate efficiency metric for equal useful output.