Nuclear Stability and Radioactive Decay — Question 3

Section 18-1 · Chemistry pages 3031–3032

Show solutionHide solution

Question 3

Compare positron emission with electron capture

A hypothetical proton-rich nucleus has A = 22 and Z = 11. Compare positron emission, p→n+e++νep\to n+e^++\nu_e, with electron capture, p+e−→n+νep+e^-\to n+\nu_e. Assume the compared modes are energetically allowed.

Diagram shown in the original SVG worksheet.

  1. Find the daughter A and Z for each mode.

  2. Explain why identical daughter nuclides do not mean identical emitted particles or identical energy requirements.

Question 3 - Solution

Compare positron emission with electron capture

Diagram shown in the original SVG worksheet.

(a) Reasoning and result

Both convert a proton into a neutron, so each daughter has A = 22, Z = 10 and N = 12.

(b) Analysis

Positron emission creates an outgoing positron and neutrino; capture consumes an atomic electron and emits a neutrino, often followed by atomic relaxation. Their mass-energy bookkeeping differs, so one mode can be allowed when the other is not.

Check and interpretation

Neither mode changes the total number of nucleons.