Show solutionHide solution
Question 8
Critique an overly simple stability rule
A student claims that every stable nucleus must have N = Z. Consider a stable light example with (N,Z) = (6,6) and a stable heavy example with (N,Z) = (126,82), supplied as facts.
Diagram shown in the original SVG worksheet.
Use the examples to evaluate the claim quantitatively.
Explain why heavier stable nuclei generally need more neutrons than protons, and why N/Z alone cannot guarantee stability.
Question 8 - Solution
Critique an overly simple stability rule
Diagram shown in the original SVG worksheet.
(a) Reasoning and result
The ratios are 1 and . The supplied heavy stable example is a counterexample to the universal claim.
(b) Analysis
Neutrons contribute to nuclear binding without adding proton-proton electrical repulsion. Shell structure, pairing and available decay energies also matter; N/Z is a useful trend, not a complete criterion.
Check and interpretation
A single counterexample disproves an unrestricted rule.