Detection and Uses of Radioactivity — Question 2

Section 18-4 · Chemistry pages 3089–3090

Show solutionHide solution

Question 2

Estimate uncertainty after subtracting background

Independent equal-duration runs give 900 gross counts and 400 background counts. Assume Poisson counting: variance equals expected count, estimated by the measured count.

Diagram shown in the original SVG worksheet.

  1. Find net counts and their estimated standard deviation.

  2. Find relative uncertainty and explain why subtracting square roots of counts is incorrect.

Question 2 - Solution

Estimate uncertainty after subtracting background

Diagram shown in the original SVG worksheet.

(a) Reasoning and result

The net is 900−400=500900-400=500 counts. For independent observations, variances add even for subtraction: σnet=900+400=36.06\sigma_{net}=\sqrt{900+400}=36.06 counts.

(b) Analysis

Relative standard uncertainty is 36.06/500=0.072136.06/500=0.0721, or 7.21 percent. Subtracting 900−400\sqrt{900}-\sqrt{400} would confuse standard deviations with signed quantities and understate fluctuation in the difference.

Check and interpretation

Background subtraction removes a mean contribution but not its counting noise.