Show solutionHide solution
Question 3
Compare total binding with binding per nucleon
Hypothetical nucleus X has A = 20 and total binding energy 160 MeV. Nucleus Y has A = 60 and total binding energy 510 MeV.
Diagram shown in the original SVG worksheet.
Calculate binding per nucleon and identify the larger average binding.
Explain why the larger total binding energy alone is not a fair comparison, and why average binding does not prove stability against every decay.
Question 3 - Solution
Compare total binding with binding per nucleon
Diagram shown in the original SVG worksheet.
(a) Reasoning and result
X has MeV/nucleon; Y has MeV/nucleon. Y has the larger average binding in this comparison.
(b) Analysis
A larger nucleus contains more nucleons and can have greater total binding simply because of size. Specific decay stability requires comparing the total rest energies of the allowed parent and product set, not just a single average.
Check and interpretation
An intensive comparison and a reaction-energy comparison answer different questions.