Thermodynamic Stability of the Nucleus — Question 8

Section 18-5 · Chemistry pages 3121–3122

Show solutionHide solution

Question 8

Evaluate an uncertain sign of Q

Use 1uc2=931.51\ \mathrm u\,c^2=931.5 MeV. A measured reactant-minus-product mass difference is (2.0±3.0)×10−5(2.0\pm3.0)\times10^{-5} u, where the stated uncertainty is one standard uncertainty. Other corrections are negligible.

Diagram shown in the original SVG worksheet.

  1. Convert the central value and uncertainty to Q in keV.

  2. Does this measurement establish an exothermic reaction? Explain without treating the uncertainty interval as an absolute bound.

Question 8 - Solution

Evaluate an uncertain sign of Q

Diagram shown in the original SVG worksheet.

(a) Reasoning and result

The estimate is Q=(0.01863±0.027945)Q=(0.01863\pm0.027945) MeV, or (18.63±27.945)(18.63\pm27.945) keV. Multiplication by the constant scales both value and uncertainty.

(b) Analysis

Zero lies within one standard uncertainty of the estimate, so the data do not establish a positive sign with strong confidence. A standard uncertainty describes measurement dispersion, not a guaranteed maximum error; a confidence claim also needs a statistical model.

Check and interpretation

Rounding a small positive central value must not erase the uncertainty.