Effects of Radiation — Question 5

Section 18-7 · Chemistry pages 3155–3156

Show solutionHide solution

Question 5

Compare spatial and temporal dose distributions

Two hypothetical samples each absorb 0.00200 J. In X it is deposited in 0.0100 kg; in Y it is uniformly deposited in 1.00 kg. Separately, two biological exposures have the same absorbed dose but are delivered over very different durations.

Diagram shown in the original SVG worksheet.

  1. Calculate D for X and Y and compare them.

  2. Explain why equal total energy, or even equal absorbed dose, does not by itself imply identical biological effects.

Question 5 - Solution

Compare spatial and temporal dose distributions

Diagram shown in the original SVG worksheet.

(a) Reasoning and result

DX=0.00200/0.0100=0.200D_X=0.00200/0.0100=0.200 Gy and DY=0.00200/1.00=0.00200D_Y=0.00200/1.00=0.00200 Gy. Local dose in X is 100 times greater.

(b) Analysis

Total energy omits the mass and spatial distribution receiving it. Even equal absorbed dose can differ in radiation type, tissue sensitivity and delivery rate, which can affect repair and response. The stated data alone cannot quantify a biological-effect ratio.

Check and interpretation

An average dose may conceal nonuniform local deposition.