A Survey of the Representative Elements — Question 7

Section 19-1 · Chemistry pages 3179–3180

Show solutionHide solution

Question 7

Use a simple polarizing-power index critically

For a qualitative comparison define P=z/r2P=z/r^2, where z is positive ionic charge number and r is radius in nm. Hypothetical cations A and B have (z,r) = (1,0.100) and (2,0.0500).

Diagram shown in the original SVG worksheet.

  1. Calculate P for each and their ratio.

  2. Predict which more strongly distorts the same anion cloud, and explain why this index alone cannot calculate an exact covalent bond fraction.

Question 7 - Solution

Use a simple polarizing-power index critically

Diagram shown in the original SVG worksheet.

(a) Reasoning and result

PA=1/(0.100)2=100nm−2P_A=1/(0.100)^2=100\ \mathrm{nm}^{-2} and PB=2/(0.0500)2=800nm−2P_B=2/(0.0500)^2=800\ \mathrm{nm}^{-2}, giving a ratio of 8.

(b) Analysis

B is predicted to polarize the anion more strongly. Actual electron sharing also depends on anion polarizability, orbital interactions and environment; the index is a trend model, not a quantitative decomposition of a bond into ionic and covalent percentages.

Check and interpretation

Use consistent radius units and identify the model as qualitative.