A Survey of the Representative Elements — Question 9

Section 19-1 · Chemistry pages 3183–3184

Show solutionHide solution

Question 9

Compare complete formation cycles rather than one energy term

For two hypothetical salts, all formation steps except cation ionization sum to -900 kJ/mol for A and -1400 kJ/mol for B. Required ionization energy is +500 kJ/mol for A and +800 kJ/mol for B. Treat these as complete enthalpy cycles per mole of salt.

Diagram shown in the original SVG worksheet.

  1. Calculate formation enthalpy for each.

  2. Evaluate the claim that the salt with the smaller ionization energy must have the more favorable formation enthalpy.

Question 9 - Solution

Compare complete formation cycles rather than one energy term

Diagram shown in the original SVG worksheet.

(a) Reasoning and result

ΔHf(A)=500−900=−400\Delta H_f(A)=500-900=-400 kJ/mol; ΔHf(B)=800−1400=−600\Delta H_f(B)=800-1400=-600 kJ/mol.

(b) Analysis

The claim fails: B has the larger ionization cost but a more exothermic total because the other steps stabilize it more strongly. Lattice, bond and other energy changes must be included; enthalpy alone also does not give Gibbs energy at arbitrary conditions.

Check and interpretation

One unfavorable step can be outweighed by favorable steps elsewhere in a cycle.