Show solutionHide solution
Question 10
Design a defensible classification from material evidence
A gray solid conducts electricity better when warmed over a modest range, unlike a reference metal whose resistance rises. The unknown is brittle and has a network structure. No chemical identity has yet been established.
Diagram shown in the original SVG worksheet.
Explain why these observations suggest semiconductor-like behavior rather than establishing a unique element.
Propose two additional measurements or controls that would strengthen the interpretation.
Question 10 - Solution
Design a defensible classification from material evidence
Diagram shown in the original SVG worksheet.
(a) Reasoning and result
Thermally increased carrier concentration can raise semiconductor conductivity, while brittleness and a network are compatible with some metalloids. Several compounds and impure materials share these features, so they do not uniquely identify an element.
(b) Analysis
Measure conductivity reproducibly over temperature with controlled contacts to exclude contact artifacts. Determine composition or crystal structure independently to distinguish an element from a compound and assess impurities. Doping and phase changes must also be considered.
Check and interpretation
Material behavior and elemental identity require complementary evidence.