Hydrogen — Question 1

Section 19-3 · Chemistry pages 3207–3208

Show solutionHide solution

Question 1

Distinguish a proton, a hydride ion and hydrogen gas

Consider isolated protium species H+H^+, H, H−H^- and H2H_2. Protium nuclei each contain one proton and no neutrons.

Diagram shown in the original SVG worksheet.

  1. Give total proton and electron counts for each species.

  2. Explain why aqueous H+H^+ is a shorthand rather than a bare isolated proton moving through liquid water.

Question 1 - Solution

Distinguish a proton, a hydride ion and hydrogen gas

Diagram shown in the original SVG worksheet.

(a) Reasoning and result

H+H^+ has (1 proton, 0 electrons); H has (1,1); H−H^- has (1,2); H2H_2 has (2,2). Charge follows the difference between proton and electron counts.

(b) Analysis

In water, the proton interacts strongly with surrounding molecules and is represented by hydrated proton structures, often abbreviated H3O+H_3O^+. The isolated-species electron count remains useful bookkeeping, but the aqueous structure includes solvent coordination.

Check and interpretation

Element identity alone does not specify charge, molecularity or chemical behavior.