The Group 2A Elements — Question 9

Section 19-4 · Chemistry pages 3243–3244

Show solutionHide solution

Question 9

Distinguish a slow surface reaction from thermodynamic inactivity

Two Group 2A metal samples are placed under a hypothetical set of identical aqueous conditions. One initially reacts slowly and has a persistent oxide layer; the other reacts more rapidly. Independent thermodynamic data predict favorable oxidation for both.

Diagram shown in the original SVG worksheet.

  1. Explain why the observations do not contradict the thermodynamic data.

  2. Identify two variables that must be controlled before interpreting the rate difference as an intrinsic periodic trend.

Question 9 - Solution

Distinguish a slow surface reaction from thermodynamic inactivity

Diagram shown in the original SVG worksheet.

(a) Reasoning and result

A surface film can hinder transport or electron transfer, producing a kinetic barrier even when oxidation is thermodynamically favorable. Reaction free energy determines direction under stated conditions, not the rate through a coated surface.

(b) Analysis

Control accessible surface area and surface preparation/film state; temperature and solution composition also matter. Without those controls, different particle sizes or coatings can mimic or obscure intrinsic chemical trends.

Check and interpretation

Visible rate is evidence about the whole reacting interface, not only the isolated element.