The Group 3A Elements — Question 3

Section 19-5 · Chemistry pages 3251–3252

Show solutionHide solution

Question 3

Explain why three hydroxyl groups do not make boric acid triprotic

Use the aqueous model B(OH)3+2H2O⇌[B(OH)4]−+H3O+B(OH)_3+2H_2O\rightleftharpoons[B(OH)_4]^-+H_3O^+. In base, the net conversion is B(OH)3+OH−→[B(OH)4]−B(OH)_3+OH^-\to[B(OH)_4]^-.

Diagram shown in the original SVG worksheet.

  1. Identify the Lewis-acid role of boron and explain how hydronium can form without treating the molecule as a conventional triprotic acid.

  2. Find hydroxide amount needed for complete conversion of 0.0150 mol B(OH)3B(OH)_3 to the stated borate species.

Question 3 - Solution

Explain why three hydroxyl groups do not make boric acid triprotic

Diagram shown in the original SVG worksheet.

(a) Reasoning and result

Boron accepts an electron pair associated with hydroxide attachment, changing from three to four hydroxyl ligands. Coupling to water produces hydronium in the stated aqueous equilibrium; counting OH groups alone does not establish three sequential proton dissociations.

(b) Analysis

The specified net reaction consumes one hydroxide per boric acid, so 0.0150 mol OH−OH^- is required, not 0.0450 mol. This result is tied to the stated product and model.

Check and interpretation

Acid behavior must be inferred from equilibria and species, not simply hydrogen count.