The Group 4A Elements — Question 3

Section 19-6 · Chemistry pages 3271–3272

Show solutionHide solution

Question 3

Derive silicate composition from shared oxygen corners

In an ideal silicate, every Si has four oxygen neighbors. Let b of the four oxygen corners per tetrahedron be bridging, each shared by exactly two tetrahedra; the other corners are unshared. Take oxidation states Si = +4 and O = -2.

Diagram shown in the original SVG worksheet.

  1. Derive O/Si and formal charge per Si as functions of b. Evaluate them for b = 2 and b = 4.

  2. For the b = 2 structure, find the number of Na+Na^+ ions required per Si to balance charge, and explain why one cannot count every shared corner as a whole oxygen.

Question 3 - Solution

Derive silicate composition from shared oxygen corners

Diagram shown in the original SVG worksheet.

(a) Reasoning and result

O/Si is (4−b)+b/2=4−b/2(4-b)+b/2=4-b/2. Charge per Si is 4−2(4−b/2)=b−44-2(4-b/2)=b-4. At b = 2 the repeat composition is SiO32−SiO_3^{2-}; at b = 4 it is neutral SiO2SiO_2. These are compositional units, not claims about isolated molecular ions.

(b) Analysis

The b = 2 unit requires two Na+Na^+ per Si, giving Na2SiO3Na_2SiO_3 stoichiometry. Counting each shared corner fully for both tetrahedra double counts the same physical oxygen.

Check and interpretation

Atom-sharing arithmetic must precede charge balance.