The Group 4A Elements — Question 6

Section 19-6 · Chemistry pages 3277–3278

Show solutionHide solution

Question 6

Use contrasting redox reactions to interpret Group 4A states

In acidic solution the following transformations are observed under suitable conditions: Sn2+Sn^{2+} becomes Sn4+Sn^{4+} while Fe3+Fe^{3+} becomes Fe2+Fe^{2+}; PbO2PbO_2 becomes Pb2+Pb^{2+} while Fe2+Fe^{2+} becomes Fe3+Fe^{3+}.

Diagram shown in the original SVG worksheet.

  1. Balance both net ionic reactions, including water and acid where required.

  2. Identify which tin or lead species is the oxidizing agent or reducing agent. Relate the contrast to the increased importance of the +2 state down Group 4A.

Question 6 - Solution

Use contrasting redox reactions to interpret Group 4A states

Diagram shown in the original SVG worksheet.

(a) Reasoning and result

Sn2++2Fe3+→Sn4++2Fe2+Sn^{2+}+2Fe^{3+}\to Sn^{4+}+2Fe^{2+}. The lead reaction is PbO2+4H++2Fe2+→Pb2++2H2O+2Fe3+PbO_2+4H^++2Fe^{2+}\to Pb^{2+}+2H_2O+2Fe^{3+}. Each transfers two electrons.

(b) Analysis

Sn2+Sn^{2+} loses electrons and is the reducing agent; Pb(IV) in PbO2PbO_2 gains electrons and is the oxidizing agent. The observations are consistent with stronger relative stabilization of the lower +2 state for lead. This is a trend conditioned by ligands and medium, not a rule excluding +4 lead compounds.

Check and interpretation

Assign oxidation states before balancing; +4 is not universally the preferred state for every Group 4A compound.