The Early History of Chemistry — Question 2

Section 2-1 · Chemistry pages 189–190

Show solutionHide solution

Question 2

Use a metal mass gain to challenge a simple loss model

In a hypothetical heating experiment, 10.00 g of a metal becomes 12.50 g of a single oxide. A simple phlogiston-style model says the metal only loses a positive-mass material; an oxygen-combination model says gas from air joins the metal. Assume no solid is lost.

Diagram shown in the original SVG worksheet.

  1. Calculate the solid mass change.

  2. Which stated model predicts the observed direction, and what extra gas measurement would strengthen it?

  3. Why should the conclusion refer to the stated simple model rather than every historical version of phlogiston?

Question 2 - Solution

Use a metal mass gain to challenge a simple loss model

Diagram shown in the original SVG worksheet.

(a) Reasoning and result

The solid gains 12.50−10.00=2.5012.50-10.00=2.50 g. A process involving only loss of positive mass would instead lower the solid mass.

(b) Analysis

The combination model predicts a gain. Measuring a 2.50 g decrease in the participating gas, with no other transfers, would quantitatively support the proposed transfer from gas to solid.

(c) Conclusion

Historical theories had variants and attempted repairs. This experiment challenges the explicitly stated loss-only prediction; it does not establish what every historical author claimed. Models must be assessed against their actual assumptions.

Check and interpretation

The solid alone is an open subsystem even when the entire apparatus is closed.