The Early History of Chemistry — Question 5

Section 2-1 · Chemistry pages 195–196

Show solutionHide solution

Question 5

Distinguish making a gas from establishing a compound

A hypothetical sample labeled water is separated by a chemical process into two identified gases. Recombining those gases in a controlled reaction yields water again. Assume contamination and side reactions have been excluded.

Diagram shown in the original SVG worksheet.

  1. Why does this challenge classifying water as a chemical element?

  2. Why is the recombination result stronger evidence than merely observing bubbles?

  3. Does this evidence alone reveal the number of atoms in a water molecule?

Question 5 - Solution

Distinguish making a gas from establishing a compound

Diagram shown in the original SVG worksheet.

(a) Reasoning and result

A chemical element cannot be decomposed into chemically simpler substances by ordinary chemical means. Producing two distinct elemental gases from pure water supports its classification as a compound.

(b) Analysis

Bubbles can arise from boiling or release of dissolved gas. Identifying both products and recreating water links the substances through a reversible chemical composition argument, rather than a visual impression.

(c) Conclusion

No. Molecular composition needs additional quantitative evidence and a particle model. The observation establishes chemical complexity without specifying an atom-count formula.

Check and interpretation

Chemical decomposition is distinct from a change of physical state.