The Early History of Chemistry — Question 8

Section 2-1 · Chemistry pages 201–202

Show solutionHide solution

Question 8

Explain why collecting gases changed mass accounting

A hypothetical carbonate-like solid of mass 15.00 g is heated to leave 9.00 g of residue. Gas is captured in a separate receiver whose mass increases by 5.85 g. No chemical identity needs to be inferred for this exercise.

Diagram shown in the original SVG worksheet.

  1. Calculate the accounted-for product mass and missing mass.

  2. Can the measurements alone establish destruction of matter?

  3. Name two experimental improvements that would help resolve the discrepancy.

Question 8 - Solution

Explain why collecting gases changed mass accounting

Diagram shown in the original SVG worksheet.

(a) Reasoning and result

Accounted products total 9.00+5.85=14.859.00+5.85=14.85 g. The shortfall is 15.00−14.85=0.1515.00-14.85=0.15 g.

(b) Analysis

No. An uncollected gas fraction, deposits in connecting tubes, or measurement error could explain the difference. A discrepancy is evidence to investigate the apparatus and accounting, not immediate proof of matter destruction.

(c) Conclusion

Check the system for leaks and weigh the complete sealed apparatus before and after. Also include material condensed in the transfer tubing and verify balance calibration. These extend the measured boundary to likely missing material.

Check and interpretation

Weighing only the residue would miss 6.00 g, whereas gas collection reduces the unexplained difference to 0.15 g.