Fundamental Chemical Laws — Question 7

Section 2-2 · Chemistry pages 219–220

Show solutionHide solution

Question 7

Do not demand exact integers from rounded measurements

For the same fixed A mass, compound P contains (1.00±0.02)(1.00\pm0.02) g B and compound Q contains (2.01±0.03)(2.01\pm0.03) g B. The plus/minus values are inclusive independent bounds.

Diagram shown in the original SVG worksheet.

  1. Find the nominal ratio mB,Q/mB,Pm_{B,Q}/m_{B,P}.

  2. Find the minimum and maximum allowed ratios and decide whether a ratio of 2 is compatible.

  3. Does compatibility prove the exact ratio or establish molecular formulas?

Question 7 - Solution

Do not demand exact integers from rounded measurements

Diagram shown in the original SVG worksheet.

(a) Reasoning and result

The nominal ratio is 2.01/1.00=2.012.01/1.00=2.01. It should not be rejected merely because the displayed value is not an integer.

(b) Analysis

The smallest ratio is 1.98/1.02=1.94117…1.98/1.02=1.94117\ldots; the largest is 2.04/0.98=2.08163…2.04/0.98=2.08163\ldots. The exact interval includes 2, so the data are compatible with a 2:1 relation.

(c) Conclusion

No. Other nearby ratios fit these bounds too. A more precise measurement could discriminate them. Even an exact mass ratio alone does not establish the atom counts in a molecular formula without additional information.

Check and interpretation

The denominator uncertainty must be included; dividing only the two central values ignores it.