Show solutionHide solution
Question 9
Recognize a composition match that is not unique identification
Compound X is reported to contain 25.0% A and 75.0% B by mass. A laboratory can also deliberately mix separate elemental A and B in the same mass proportions. Assume the components do not react during mixing.
Diagram shown in the original SVG worksheet.
For a 20.0 g sample, calculate the A and B masses in either preparation.
Would elemental mass analysis alone distinguish the compound from that mixture?
Propose an additional kind of evidence that can distinguish chemical combination from mechanical mixing.
Question 9 - Solution
Recognize a composition match that is not unique identification
Diagram shown in the original SVG worksheet.
(a) Reasoning and result
Both preparations contain g A and g B. The bulk mass fractions match.
(b) Analysis
No. Elemental mass analysis records how much of each element is present, not necessarily how the atoms are bonded or arranged. The compound and deliberately mixed sample can share the same result.
(c) Conclusion
Validated physical separation of the unchanged components would support a mixture; structural or spectroscopic evidence could show a distinct compound. A proposed method must actually distinguish the materials, rather than assume every mixture can be filtered.
Check and interpretation
Definite composition is required for this compound but is not by itself a unique signature of it.