Show solutionHide solution
Question 4
Expose a formula assumption hidden in an atomic-mass estimate
A pure binary compound has B:A mass ratio 8:1. Investigator P assumes its particles are AB and sets the mass of A to 1 unit. Investigator Q instead assumes using the same A mass unit.
Diagram shown in the original SVG worksheet.
What B atomic mass does P infer?
What B atomic mass does Q infer?
Why can bulk composition alone not select the correct formula and atomic mass simultaneously?
Question 4 - Solution
Expose a formula assumption hidden in an atomic-mass estimate
Diagram shown in the original SVG worksheet.
(a) Reasoning and result
For AB, , so P infers units.
(b) Analysis
For , the B:A mass ratio is . With , Q infers units.
(c) Conclusion
The measurement constrains a product of atom-count ratios and atom-mass ratios. Different formula assumptions can reproduce it with different masses. Independent information about particle composition or relative masses is needed to remove the ambiguity.
Check and interpretation
Both assumed models give eight B mass units per one A mass unit in the bulk compound.