Dalton’s Atomic Theory — Question 7

Section 2-3 · Chemistry pages 239–240

Show solutionHide solution

Question 7

State the boundary of a chemical model

Process I rearranges A and B atoms into AB without changing their nuclei. Process II changes a nucleus so that its proton count increases by one. Assume Process II is a nuclear event, not ordinary chemistry.

Diagram shown in the original SVG worksheet.

  1. Which process lies within Dalton's ordinary chemical-rearrangement model?

  2. In which process does the element identity of an atom change?

  3. Why is it important to specify the model's domain rather than say atoms can never change?

Question 7 - Solution

State the boundary of a chemical model

Diagram shown in the original SVG worksheet.

(a) Reasoning and result

Process I lies within the chemical model: atoms are rearranged into new combinations while maintaining their elemental identities.

(b) Analysis

In II the proton count changes, so the nucleus belongs to a different element. This is outside the ordinary chemical processes being modeled.

(c) Conclusion

The absolute statement would incorrectly extend a useful chemical approximation to nuclear phenomena. A model should specify the processes for which its assumptions and conservation rules are being applied.

Check and interpretation

New compounds can form without new elements forming.