Show solutionHide solution
Question 7
State the boundary of a chemical model
Process I rearranges A and B atoms into AB without changing their nuclei. Process II changes a nucleus so that its proton count increases by one. Assume Process II is a nuclear event, not ordinary chemistry.
Diagram shown in the original SVG worksheet.
Which process lies within Dalton's ordinary chemical-rearrangement model?
In which process does the element identity of an atom change?
Why is it important to specify the model's domain rather than say atoms can never change?
Question 7 - Solution
State the boundary of a chemical model
Diagram shown in the original SVG worksheet.
(a) Reasoning and result
Process I lies within the chemical model: atoms are rearranged into new combinations while maintaining their elemental identities.
(b) Analysis
In II the proton count changes, so the nucleus belongs to a different element. This is outside the ordinary chemical processes being modeled.
(c) Conclusion
The absolute statement would incorrectly extend a useful chemical approximation to nuclear phenomena. A model should specify the processes for which its assumptions and conservation rules are being applied.
Check and interpretation
New compounds can form without new elements forming.