Dalton’s Atomic Theory — Question 10

Section 2-3 · Chemistry pages 245–246

Show solutionHide solution

Question 10

Change the mass unit without changing the chemistry

In an arbitrary relative-mass scale, A has atomic mass 2 and B has atomic mass 6. A hypothetical compound consists of AB2AB_2 particles. A second scale assigns A a mass of 10 while describing the same atoms.

Diagram shown in the original SVG worksheet.

  1. Find the B mass and AB2AB_2 particle mass on both scales.

  2. Calculate the B mass fraction on each scale.

  3. Explain which features depend on the unit choice and which remain invariant.

Question 10 - Solution

Change the mass unit without changing the chemistry

Diagram shown in the original SVG worksheet.

(a) Reasoning and result

The scale factor is 10/2=510/2=5. On the first scale B is 6 and AB2AB_2 is 2+2(6)=142+2(6)=14. On the second B is 30 and the particle is 10+2(30)=7010+2(30)=70.

(b) Analysis

First scale: 12/14=6/712/14=6/7. Second scale: 60/70=6/760/70=6/7. The B fraction is unchanged, about 85.7%.

(c) Conclusion

Numerical masses depend on the selected unit. Atom counts, the 1:2 formula ratio, atomic-mass ratios and mass fractions do not. Rescaling a unit does not alter the chemical model.

Check and interpretation

All masses must be multiplied by the same factor; changing only one would describe different relative masses.