Early Experiments to Characterize the Atom — Question 6

Section 2-4 · Chemistry pages 257–258

Show solutionHide solution

Question 6

Use rare large-angle scattering without overstating the result

In a hypothetical thin-foil experiment, 10,000 detected alpha particles are classified as 9,920 nearly forward, 70 moderately deflected and 10 deflected through large angles. Assume equal detection efficiency for these exhaustive bins. Alpha particles are positive; the nuclear model concentrates atomic positive charge and most mass in a small region.

Diagram shown in the original SVG worksheet.

  1. Find the percentage in each bin.

  2. Explain how the two observations—mostly forward and a few large deflections—constrain an atomic model together.

  3. Does the 0.1% large-angle fraction directly equal the fraction of atomic volume occupied by nuclei?

Question 6 - Solution

Use rare large-angle scattering without overstating the result

Diagram shown in the original SVG worksheet.

(a) Reasoning and result

The fractions are 99.2%99.2\%, 0.7%0.7\% and 0.1%0.1\%, respectively, and sum to 100%.

(b) Analysis

Most trajectories do not encounter a region causing strong deflection, while a few encounter strong localized interactions. In the electrostatic nuclear account, this supports concentrated scattering centers rather than positive charge smoothly spread through the full atomic volume.

(c) Conclusion

No. Scattering probability depends on angle threshold, interaction strength, incident energy, target thickness and detection geometry. It is not a direct geometrical volume measurement.

Check and interpretation

A small but reliable class of observations can distinguish models even when most events look similar.