The Modern View of Atomic Structure: An Introduction — Question 3

Section 2-5 · Chemistry pages 271–272

Show solutionHide solution

Question 3

Separate isotope relationships from equal mass numbers

Compare neutral 1840Ar{}^{40}_{18}\mathrm{Ar}, 2040Ca{}^{40}_{20}\mathrm{Ca} and 2042Ca{}^{42}_{20}\mathrm{Ca}. Isotopes have the same proton count and different neutron counts. Different elements with the same mass number are called isobars.

Diagram shown in the original SVG worksheet.

  1. Find the neutron count of each atom.

  2. Which pair are isotopes, and which pair are isobars?

  3. Why does mass number alone fail to identify an element?

Question 3 - Solution

Separate isotope relationships from equal mass numbers

Diagram shown in the original SVG worksheet.

(a) Reasoning and result

Neutron counts are 40−18=2240-18=22 for argon-40, 40−20=2040-20=20 for calcium-40 and 42−20=2242-20=22 for calcium-42.

(b) Analysis

Calcium-40 and calcium-42 are isotopes: both have 20 protons. Argon-40 and calcium-40 are isobars: both have mass number 40 but different proton counts.

(c) Conclusion

The sum p+np+n can be the same for different values of pp. Proton count determines element identity; equal nucleon totals do not require equal nuclear charge.

Check and interpretation

Argon-40 and calcium-42 share a neutron count but are not isotopes of one element.