Show solutionHide solution
Question 8
Audit an inconsistent subatomic-particle table
A draft table lists as 8 protons, 10 neutrons and 8 electrons, and as 10 protons, 13 neutrons and 10 electrons. The nuclide symbols are the intended species.
Diagram shown in the original SVG worksheet.
Correct all three particle counts for the oxygen ion.
Correct all three counts for the sodium ion.
Identify the different mistaken ideas that could have produced the two rows.
Question 8 - Solution
Audit an inconsistent subatomic-particle table
Diagram shown in the original SVG worksheet.
(a) Reasoning and result
has eight protons, neutrons and ten electrons, since .
(b) Analysis
has eleven protons, neutrons and ten electrons, since .
(c) Conclusion
The oxygen row incorrectly put the two added negative-charge carriers into the neutron count. The sodium row incorrectly removed a proton to represent positive ion formation, then adjusted neutrons to preserve A. Ordinary ion formation changes electrons, not nuclear identity.
Check and interpretation
Check each corrected row with both and .