Show solutionHide solution
Question 10
Decide what an electron count leaves undetermined
Three species each have 18 electrons. Candidate identities include neutral argon (), chloride with charge (), and calcium with charge (). No isotope mass numbers are given.
Diagram shown in the original SVG worksheet.
Verify the electron count of each candidate.
Can electron count alone determine element, charge or neutron count?
What additional information would determine all three particle counts for one species?
Question 10 - Solution
Decide what an electron count leaves undetermined
Diagram shown in the original SVG worksheet.
(a) Reasoning and result
Argon has electrons; chloride has ; calcium ion has . These are isoelectronic species: equal electron counts.
(b) Analysis
No. Different proton counts and charges yield the same electron count. Neutron count is also undetermined because isotope mass numbers have not been supplied.
(c) Conclusion
Given electron count, a measured charge gives and identifies the element. A mass number then gives . Equivalently, a full nuclide symbol with charge determines all counts.
Check and interpretation
Isoelectronic does not mean same element, same isotope or identical chemical behavior.