Molecules and Ions — Question 5

Section 2-6 · Chemistry pages 295–296

Show solutionHide solution

Question 5

Conserve electrons while forming oppositely charged ions

One neutral Mg atom and two neutral Cl atoms form Mg2+Mg^{2+} and two Cl−Cl^-. Magnesium has Z=12Z=12 and chlorine has Z=17Z=17. Consider electron transfer only; nuclear identities do not change.

Diagram shown in the original SVG worksheet.

  1. How many electrons does each species have before and after?

  2. Write the electron-loss and electron-gain statements and show that transferred electrons cancel.

  3. Calculate the total charge and total electron count of the final three ions.

Question 5 - Solution

Conserve electrons while forming oppositely charged ions

Diagram shown in the original SVG worksheet.

(a) Reasoning and result

Mg starts with 12 electrons and ends with 10. Each Cl starts with 17 and ends with 18. Mg loses two; each Cl gains one.

(b) Analysis

Mg→Mg2++2e−Mg\longrightarrow Mg^{2+}+2e^- and 2Cl+2e−→2Cl−2Cl+2e^-\longrightarrow2Cl^-. Adding them cancels the two transferred electrons, which move between atoms rather than vanish.

(c) Conclusion

The final charge is +2e−2e=0+2e-2e=0. Electrons total 10+2(18)=4610+2(18)=46, the same as 12+2(17)=4612+2(17)=46 initially. A neutral collection can consist of charged constituents.

Check and interpretation

Proton counts remain 12 and 17; ion formation is not a change of element.