Molecules and Ions — Question 7

Section 2-6 · Chemistry pages 299–300

Show solutionHide solution

Question 7

Distinguish multiplying molecules from changing one molecule

Compare the notation 3H2O3H_2O with the formal single-particle formula H6O3H_6O_3. The second is only a notation exercise; no claim is made that it describes an ordinary stable molecule.

Diagram shown in the original SVG worksheet.

  1. Compare the total H and O counts in the two expressions.

  2. How does the grouping of atoms differ?

  3. Explain why changing subscripts to balance a reaction is generally incorrect.

Question 7 - Solution

Distinguish multiplying molecules from changing one molecule

Diagram shown in the original SVG worksheet.

(a) Reasoning and result

Both expressions contain six H and three O atoms in total.

(b) Analysis

3H2O3H_2O specifies three separate water molecules, each with two H and one O. H6O3H_6O_3 specifies one formal particle with all nine atoms. Equal totals do not imply identical chemical particles.

(c) Conclusion

Coefficients change how many particles take part; subscripts change the stated composition of each particle and usually its identity. A balanced reaction must preserve the formulas of the specified substances while choosing suitable coefficients.

Check and interpretation

Atom conservation alone does not authorize replacing one species with another.