Show solutionHide solution
Question 2
Choose a related family rather than a neighboring box
The fragment places Na and Li in group 1, Mg and Be in group 2, and Cl and F in group 17. Elements in the same main group often show related chemical behavior.
Diagram shown in the original SVG worksheet.
Which is a closer family analogue of Na: Li or Mg? Explain using the table.
Name the families containing Na, Mg and Cl.
Does being beside Na in the same row guarantee Mg behaves more like Na than Li does?
Question 2 - Solution
Choose a related family rather than a neighboring box
Diagram shown in the original SVG worksheet.
(a) Reasoning and result
Li is the closer family analogue because both occupy group 1. They share the characteristic alkali-metal pattern of forming monatomic ions in many compounds.
(b) Analysis
Na belongs to the alkali metals; Mg to the alkaline earth metals; Cl to the halogens.
(c) Conclusion
No. Horizontal proximity alone is not a rule for closest chemical similarity. Group membership captures a recurring pattern; neighboring elements in a period can have different common charges and properties.
Check and interpretation
Family similarity is useful, but it is not a claim that every property is equal.