An Introduction to the Periodic Table — Question 5

Section 2-7 · Chemistry pages 315–316

Show solutionHide solution

Question 5

Use a compound formula to constrain an unknown group member

An unknown period-3 nonmetal X forms a monatomic ion and an ionic compound MgX2MgX_2 with Mg2+Mg^{2+}. Restrict candidates to P, S and Cl in the supplied table and use their common monatomic charges P3−P^{3-}, S2−S^{2-} and Cl−Cl^-.

Diagram shown in the original SVG worksheet.

  1. Infer the charge of X from electrical neutrality.

  2. Identify X and give its group and atomic number.

  3. Explain why choosing sulfur solely because it is also a period-3 nonmetal would fail.

Question 5 - Solution

Use a compound formula to constrain an unknown group member

Diagram shown in the original SVG worksheet.

(a) Reasoning and result

For one Mg ion and two X ions, 2+2qX=02+2q_X=0, so each X ion has charge −1-1.

(b) Analysis

Only chloride has the required charge among the specified candidates. X is Cl, group 17, atomic number 17.

(c) Conclusion

Two S2−S^{2-} ions with one Mg2+Mg^{2+} would total charge −2-2, not zero. A neutral magnesium sulfide ratio is 1:1, so the supplied 1:2 formula excludes sulfide under the assumptions.

Check and interpretation

Table location narrows candidates; charge balance selects among them.