Show solutionHide solution
Question 7
Recognize limits of a simple group shortcut
Hydrogen appears above group 1 but is a nonmetal under ordinary conditions. Helium is in group 18 and has two electrons in a filled first shell. A student asserts: every group-1 element is an alkali metal, and every group-18 atom must have eight electrons in its outer shell.
Diagram shown in the original SVG worksheet.
Use the supplied facts to evaluate both assertions.
Why can helium still belong with the noble gases despite having two rather than eight outer electrons?
Explain why periodic-table patterns should be used with stated exceptions rather than as unrestricted slogans.
Question 7 - Solution
Recognize limits of a simple group shortcut
Diagram shown in the original SVG worksheet.
(a) Reasoning and result
Both universal assertions are false. Hydrogen is the stated group-1 nonmetal exception; helium has a filled two-electron first shell rather than an eight-electron outer shell.
(b) Analysis
Helium shares the characteristic filled-shell, low-reactivity pattern of the noble-gas family. The capacity of its first shell differs from the later shells involved in the familiar octet pattern.
(c) Conclusion
Placement summarizes recurring chemical and electronic patterns, but simple mnemonics omit details. A rule should identify its scope and known exceptions so it helps predict behavior without overriding contrary evidence.
Check and interpretation
Group membership is not a statement that all members have the same total electron count.