The Group 5A Elements — Question 6

Section 20-1 · Chemistry pages 3297–3298

Show solutionHide solution

Question 6

Apply an octet constraint without inventing orbitals

A proposed neutral molecule NCl5NCl_5 is drawn with five ordinary two-center, two-electron single bonds at nitrogen. In contrast, a molecular gas-phase model of PCl5PCl_5 has five P-Cl connections.

Diagram shown in the original SVG worksheet.

  1. Count electrons placed around N by the proposed drawing and assess it using the usual second-period octet constraint.

  2. Explain why the existence of a phosphorus pentahalide does not validate the nitrogen drawing or prove that phosphorus must use five equivalent localized hybrid orbitals.

Question 6 - Solution

Apply an octet constraint without inventing orbitals

Diagram shown in the original SVG worksheet.

(a) Reasoning and result

Five single bonds place ten shared electrons around nitrogen, violating the usual octet limit for a conventional second-period Lewis structure. The proposed ordinary-bond drawing is therefore unsuitable.

(b) Analysis

Elements in the same group need not have identical coordination chemistry. Heavier-element hypervalent bonding can be described through delocalized and ionic contributions; coordination number does not establish a unique hybrid-orbital mechanism. The simple octet-limited nitrogen model should not be transferred uncritically to phosphorus.

Check and interpretation

Electron counting constrains a model; it is not itself an experimental structure determination.