The Group 5A Elements — Question 7

Section 20-1 · Chemistry pages 3299–3300

Show solutionHide solution

Question 7

Use redox evidence for a lower oxidation state

For a hypothetical acidic medium, take Bi(V)+2e−→Bi(III)Bi(V)+2e^-\to Bi(III) with reduction potential 1.60 V and M3++e−→M2+M^{3+}+e^-\to M^{2+} with potential 0.80 V. Bi(V) and Bi(III) denote the specified oxidation-state couple, not bare aqueous ions.

Diagram shown in the original SVG worksheet.

  1. Calculate the standard cell potential for reducing Bi(V) with M2+M^{2+} and the Gibbs energy per mole of two-electron reaction, using F = 96485 C/mol.

  2. Explain what this shows about Bi(III) in this medium and what it does not prove about every bismuth compound.

Question 7 - Solution

Use redox evidence for a lower oxidation state

Diagram shown in the original SVG worksheet.

(a) Reasoning and result

Ecell∘=1.60−0.80=0.80E^\circ_{cell}=1.60-0.80=0.80 V. Two M(II) centers are oxidized per Bi(V) center reduced; ΔG∘=−2F(0.80)=−154376\Delta G^\circ=-2F(0.80)=-154376 J/mol = -154.4 kJ/mol.

(b) Analysis

The supplied redox pair favors reduction to Bi(III), consistent with the importance of the lower +3 state for heavier Group 5A elements. Ligands and medium alter relative stability, so the conclusion is not that all Bi(V) compounds are impossible.

Check and interpretation

Multiply electron numbers in the balanced reaction, not the tabulated reduction potentials.