The Chemistry of Phosphorus — Question 6

Section 20-3 · Chemistry pages 3337–3338

Show solutionHide solution

Question 6

Distinguish gaseous and crystalline phosphorus pentachloride

Use these structural descriptions: gas-phase molecular PCl5PCl_5 is trigonal bipyramidal, whereas a common crystalline form is represented as [PCl4]+[PCl6]−[PCl_4]^+[PCl_6]^-.

Diagram shown in the original SVG worksheet.

  1. Verify that the ionic crystal representation has the same overall P:Cl ratio as PCl5PCl_5, and state the local P coordination numbers.

  2. Explain why an empirical formula alone cannot determine the molecular geometry or even whether a phase consists of discrete neutral molecules.

Question 6 - Solution

Distinguish gaseous and crystalline phosphorus pentachloride

Diagram shown in the original SVG worksheet.

(a) Reasoning and result

One cation-anion pair contains two P atoms and ten Cl atoms, giving a 1:5 ratio. Gas-phase P has five neighbors; the cation has four and the anion six. The ionic pair has zero total charge.

(b) Analysis

Composition counts atoms but does not specify connectivity or charge distribution. Phase and conditions matter: the same bulk ratio may describe a molecular gas and an ionic crystal. The two different local geometries in the crystal cannot be replaced by a single gas-phase molecular drawing.

Check and interpretation

Coordination number is not the same as oxidation state: P remains formally +5 in both complex ions.