Show solutionHide solution
Question 10
Audit a phosphorus recovery claim
A hypothetical water-treatment batch contains 100.0 g total P. Measurements find 12.0 g in treated water, 70.0 g in a recovered solid and 15.0 g in residual sludge. No other input is present.
Diagram shown in the original SVG worksheet.
Calculate mass-balance closure, unaccounted P and recovered-product yield relative to feed.
Evaluate a claim of 88 percent useful phosphorus recovery based only on the decrease in dissolved P.
Question 10 - Solution
Audit a phosphorus recovery claim
Diagram shown in the original SVG worksheet.
(a) Reasoning and result
Accounted P is g, giving 97 percent closure and 3 g unaccounted. Useful recovered solid contains 70 g P, or 70 percent of feed.
(b) Analysis
The 88 percent decrease in water-phase P includes P diverted to sludge and any unaccounted fraction. Removal from water is not identical to recovery as useful product. Sampling, retained material and analytical uncertainty should be examined before assigning the missing 3 g to any specific process.
Check and interpretation
Recovery, removal and inventory closure have different denominators and meanings.