The Group 6A Elements — Question 4

Section 20-4 · Chemistry pages 3353–3354

Show solutionHide solution

Question 4

Compare hydride acidity on a logarithmic scale

Use supplied aqueous first-dissociation pKapK_a values H2S=7.0H_2S=7.0 and H2Se=3.9H_2Se=3.9 under the same idealized conditions. Both initially have concentration 0.0100 mol/L. Ignore second dissociation and water autoionization.

Diagram shown in the original SVG worksheet.

  1. Find the ratio Ka(H2Se)/Ka(H2S)K_a(H_2Se)/K_a(H_2S).

  2. Use the exact quadratic for H2SeH_2Se to find its hydrogen-ion concentration and explain why a stronger acid does not imply a stronger H-E bond.

Question 4 - Solution

Compare hydride acidity on a logarithmic scale

Diagram shown in the original SVG worksheet.

(a) Reasoning and result

The ratio is 10−3.9/10−7.0=103.1=1258.910^{-3.9}/10^{-7.0}=10^{3.1}=1258.9, so the supplied selenium hydride is the stronger acid.

(b) Analysis

With K=10−3.9K=10^{-3.9}, x=[−K+K2+4KC0]/2=1.06084×10−3x=[-K+\sqrt{K^2+4KC_0}]/2=1.06084\times10^{-3} mol/L (pH 2.9744). About 10.6 percent dissociates, so a very-small-x approximation is not accurate here. Acidity reflects a complete proton-transfer free energy; weakening an H-E bond can facilitate rather than oppose acid dissociation.

Check and interpretation

Equal starting concentration is not equal pH; acid strength is not the concentration itself.