Show solutionHide solution
Question 9
Use isotope labeling to identify an oxygen source
In a hypothetical photosynthetic labeling experiment, newly evolved oxygen is 80 atom percent . Water oxygen is 80 atom percent but carbon-dioxide oxygen is only 1 percent. Assume no isotope exchange, negligible isotope discrimination and only these two possible sources.
Diagram shown in the original SVG worksheet.
Use an atom-fraction mixing balance to infer the fraction of evolved oxygen atoms originating from water.
Explain why isotope exchange or a delay in sampling could undermine the inference, and distinguish an atom fraction from a fraction of molecules.
Question 9 - Solution
Use isotope labeling to identify an oxygen source
Diagram shown in the original SVG worksheet.
(a) Reasoning and result
Let f be the water-derived atom fraction. Then , giving . Under the assumptions all evolved oxygen atoms are water-derived.
(b) Analysis
Exchange can move labels between reservoirs before oxygen evolution, and timing can mix old and new inventories. Also 80 percent labeled atoms does not mean 80 percent fully labeled molecules; random pairing would give as , with mixed isotopologues also present.
Check and interpretation
The inference identifies atom origin only under the stated tracer assumptions.