The Group 7A Elements — Question 3

Section 20-7 · Chemistry pages 3411–3412

Show solutionHide solution

Question 3

Explain why HF is a weak acid despite strongly polar bonding

In dilute water, HF is a weak acid while HCl is treated as a strong acid. Use illustrative gas-phase H-X bond enthalpies H-F = 565 and H-Cl = 431 kJ/mol.

Diagram shown in the original SVG worksheet.

  1. Explain why high H-F bond polarity alone is insufficient to predict complete aqueous dissociation.

  2. Calculate the bond-enthalpy difference and explain why it cannot be equated directly with the difference in aqueous acid dissociation free energies.

Question 3 - Solution

Explain why HF is a weak acid despite strongly polar bonding

Diagram shown in the original SVG worksheet.

(a) Reasoning and result

Acid dissociation depends on the overall free-energy change for proton transfer and solvation. The strong H-F bond resists cleavage even though it is polar; bond polarity is only one contribution to the aqueous balance.

(b) Analysis

The supplied difference is 565−431=134565-431=134 kJ/mol. Bond dissociation enthalpies describe a gas-phase homolytic process, while aqueous acidity concerns ion formation, hydration and entropy. Subtracting these bond enthalpies does not isolate the full acid dissociation free-energy difference.

Check and interpretation

Neither electronegativity nor one bond-energy term determines aqueous acidity on its own.